Monday, February 9, 2026

A Beautiful and Terrible Murder written by Claire M. Andrews, reviewed by Klaudia Janek

Summary: Set in Victorian-era Oxford, "A Beautiful and Terrible Murder" follows Irene Adler as she navigates a world of gender roles and power while disguised as Isaac Holland to study at the prestigious All Souls College. As a series of gruesome murders unfolds, Irene and her brilliant classmate Sherlock Holmes team up to uncover the identity of the killer.  The story weaves classic characters like Watson and Moriarty into a fresh narrative, blending mystery and intrigue with a touch of romance. Irene Adler is Dean Moriarty's illegitmate daughter and her half-brother is James Moriarty. Irene's dual identity adds complexity, emphasizing themes of identity and perseverance in a male-dominated society. 

Straight Talk for Librarians: This engaging reimagining of the Sherlock Holmes universe places Irene Adler at the forefront, offering a fresh perspective on beloved characters. The plot's fast pace and witty dialogue make for fun read. I love the setting, the mystery, the dialogue and the cover! The setting provides a rich backdrop for discussions on historical context, while the mystery offers opportunities for critical thinking and analysis. The story really paints the picture of a rough and tumble Victorian society, where the wealthy were trying to keep control over many aspects of society. Recommended for young adult readers seeking a blend of mystery, history, and character-driven storytelling.  There are descriptions of the murdered bodies, so I would keep this in the hands of high school readers and recommend Enola Holmes to middle grade readers.  There is also a hint of romance, which makes the book even more fun.  I loved it and am happy to recommend to any high school students looking for a good mystery.

No comments:

Post a Comment