Crow Mountain written by Lucy Inglis, reviewed by Bethany Bratney

Summary: Hope is visiting Montana while her mother does research on a ranch with a particularly undisturbed ecosystem. While there, Hope meets Cal Crow, ranch hand and son of the owner. Despite an immediate attraction, they maintain a friendly relationship while Cal takes Hope under his wing and teaches her about ranch life. Hope finds an old, abandoned journal at the ranch and begins reading it, which kicks off the second narrative of another British girl in Montana, Emily, who is rescued in a time of crisis by a horse-trader named Nate. The story moves back and forth between Hope and Emily as each explores her new environment, finds herself in dark and dangerous moments, and is forced to engage in a partnership with a local liaison. When Hope and Cal are stranded in similar fashion to Emily and Nate, the parallels to the stories become increasingly strong and Hope begins to make connections between Emily’s life in the past, and the Crow family in the present. 

Straight Talk for Librarians: What a pleasant surprise! Both of the narratives encompassed in this book are equally engaging. The characters are fully-fleshed out, complete with complicated back stories and significant flaws, but I was rooting hard for all of them. This book has all of the longing and tension that romance readers are looking for times two, but the relationships are developed reasonably and realistically without the incorporation of insta-love, a common plot device of YA romance. The inclusion of nature and ecology in Montana might allow for a science connection. Emily and Nate’s story offers a lens into early frontier days in 1867, offering a history curriculum connection as well. Both story lines include plot elements that highlight the tense relationships between Native people in Montana and those who eventually settled the land that was stolen from them. Nate, in particular, is able to offer significant insight without crossing the line into cultural appropriation as he is a young white man whose mother married a Blackfoot man, allowing him to live amongst the tribe and have Blackfoot half-siblings, without forcing him into an identity that he cannot rightfully assume. Both Hope and Emily, by the end of their respective stories, have grown incredibly in self-reliance and self-confidence, making them not only excellent characters to follow, but fantastic role models for young women today.