Thursday, December 22, 2022
Cecil's Pride, written by Craig Hatkoff, Juliana Hatkoff, and Isabella Hatkoff, reviewed by Debra Gantz
Cleo Edison, Playground Millionaire, written by Sundee Tucker Frazier, reviewed by Debra Gantz
Straight Talk for Librarians: I am a bit torn on this book. The vocabulary for building budding entrepreneurs, the attachments I fear for children watching TV programs, and using the internet without supervision is what bothered me. There is so much valuable vocabulary and the connections to how media may affect people with powers of persuasion, obsession, and connection are unsurpassed by any other book I have read. This book has some major issues to note: adoption is not just about love, but also about loss. Divorce and new families extending your family affects kids at their souls and is sometimes overpowering. We all need people in our lives to recognize our battles and help us move forward despite them. Teachers who read this book are likely to realize some of the traditional projects, like family trees, inherently involve big feelings and possibly some outbursts from students who have more than one tree to create. Giving adults and children a chance to express their thoughts on how Cleo handles her feelings about the woman who gave her up for adoption and her adoptive family and how Caylee handles her father leaving and starting a new family and where that leaves her are important conversations. I love how Cleo grows in this story and begins to recognize her business dreams may affect others.
I will forever believe that how students grow in this world is helped along by books with issues. Characters having issues allows us to build compassion, empathy, and may help us to handle our own baggage in better and kinder ways.
Friday, December 16, 2022
Trouble Next Door, written by Karen English, reviewed by Debra Gantz
A good purchase if you need more chapter books in your collection.
Straight Talk for Librarians: There is some chatter about bullying, foster care situations, and science fair projects gone wrong (and right), but nothing inappropriate or hard to handle in the grand scheme of things. If you need a series for young readers with many characters of color experiencing school in the suburbs this may fit.
Thursday, December 15, 2022
Everybody Needs a Buddy (The Big Idea Gang) written by James Preller, reviewed by Debra Gantz
The short chapters with illustration support are perfect for 2nd-4th grade chapter book readers and the enthusiasm and humor of this group of characters will encourage students to read and consider the problem of how to inspire others when you have a good idea for your community. Miss Zip, their teacher, offers persuasive writing ideas after the story and ties it all together in a nice writing lesson bow that teachers are sure to love.
I did notice a few editing mistakes (missed words) as I read, but all in all this is a solid addition for my two elementary school collections.
Straight Talk for Librarians: Great series for those who serve elementary school populations and want a way to encourage writing for fun and for persuasion.
Worst Mascot Ever (The Big Idea Gang), written by James Preller, reviewed by Debra Gantz
Summary: The creation of the Big Idea Gang is in response to the mascot of the Armadillo making no sense since there are not any in Connecticut. There is opposition in class when they put the idea out there that the Armadillo is a horrible mascot, so they decide on a vote. The backmatter: Miss Zip's "Wow Me" Tips is wonderfully done and easily lends itself to a writing lesson!
Straight Talk for Librarians: I love this series for the writing connections in the stories and in a section at the back of the books. Many students have great ideas, but struggle to expand them. This series is a nice connection for classroom writing work.
Bee the Change (The Big Idea Gang), written by James Preller, reviewed by Debra Gantz
There is back matter on bees after the story as well as a section about writing entitled "Wow Me Tips". This writing section is what captured my 3rd grade teaching teams and got them excited about sharing this title (and the series) with classes next year.
Straight Talk for Librarians: I loved that it is an easy chapter book that my 2nd-4th graders may find interesting. I loved even more the facts in this title about bees, which are not being supported enough these days. I shared it with my 3rd grade teams in both of buildings as the writing connections at the end are wonderful.
(The book ends with both back matter about bees and notes from their teacher about writing. Teachers at both of my schools love the series for the writing information!)
Wednesday, December 14, 2022
Recess is a Jungle (Eerie Elementary #3), written by Jack Chabert, illustrated by Sam Ricks, reviewed by Debra Gantz
The Science Fair is Freaky! (Eerie Elementary #4), written by Jack Chabert, illustrated by Sam Ricks, reviewed by Debra Gantz
Straight Talk for Librarians: My elementary school students love this series from the Scholastic Branches collection. I love the short chapters and the extra white space as well as the illustrations by Sam Ricks that are engaging and helpful for new chapter book readers building reading stamina and comprehension strength. As always, there are some questions at the end that may help students and/or their parents as they read and discuss the story together.
Rise of Herk (Nnewts #2), written by Doug TenNapel, reviewed by Debra Gantz
Straight Talk for Librarians: I was very impressed with this story. The story was interesting and heart-warming and the adventure has amazing details and connections. I have not recently read the first and will return to it before reading the 3rd book.
Jack and the Snackstalk (Princess Pink and the Land of Fake-Believe #4), written by Noah Jones, reviewed by Debra Gantz
Straight Talk for Librarians: This Branches series has been very popular for my students. I love Traditional Tales and talk about them a lot, so conversations around these stories have been wonderful!
Ricky Ricotta's Mighty Robot vs. The Unpleasant Penguins from Pluto, written by Dav Pilkey, art by Dan Santat, reviewed by Debra Gantz
I have always felt this series to be better than Captain Underpants, but my students resoundingly choose undergarment humor. I did get more students this year reading Mighty Robot and I am pleased to have this title to add to my collection! These two masters of children's book writing and illustrating continue to impress in this edition.
Straight Talk for Librarians: Dav Pilkey remains the master of the early reader novel, especially when you need silliness and wild action with a flip o rama section for added joy! The illustrations by Dan Santat will increase the smiles for this title.
Rumble of the Coaster Ghost (Notebook of Doom #9), written by Troy Cummings, reviewed by Debra Gantz
My students love these Branches series books and this series The Notebook of Doom is a favorite, for sure.
Straight Talk for Librarians: Short chapters with white space and illustrations to allow for success for your early chapter book readers in your library population. There are questions at the end to guide discussions. Buy as needed to support your students' needs and interests.
Tooth Bandits (Stella and the Night Sprites #2), written by Sam Hay, reviewed by Debra Gantz
Straight Talk for Librarians: Branches is a super popular group of series books in my library due to our Scholastic Book Fairs. I do not have many of this particular series, but it is the same format and I am sure it will be loved! I like the questions at the end of the book to guide discussion and thinking about the story characters. I love the limited words on a page and the extra wordless space (I often say white space, but this one has more gray space than white.)
Sweet Buttercup (Silver Pony Ranch #2), written by D.L. Green, reviewed by Debra Gantz
Sweet Buttercup is the second of this series. Tori and her sister, Miranda, are at Grandma's ranch for the summer. The horses, her grandma's dogs, and spending time with their grandma brings obvious joy for the girls. They meet a new girl who is boarding her horse at the ranch and is going to a local horse show that Tori and Miranda are a bit nervous about entering. Ashley is abrupt and pointed with her comments and seems to need to be better than Tori. Their grandma encourages them to give Ashley a chance despite that and when Ashley is in a bind at a horse show, Tori steps up to help.
Straight Talk for Librarians: Short chapters and learning some facts about riding is a big draw for many of my students in both of my schools. I love the focus on choice in this story. There are choices with how we speak to others as well as choices in how we react to others. These characters allow that learning to happen naturally. I recommend the Branches series books often as their is something for everyone. This one, quite obviously, will be for my animal lovers!
Some Other Now, written by Sarah Everett, reviewed by Bethany Bratney
Tuesday, December 13, 2022
Duck, Duck, Moose, written by Mary Sullivan, reviewed by Katy Golden
Straight Talk for Librarians:
The song-like rhythm of the text and frequently repeated words make this an engaging read-aloud for younger students, who might find themselves chanting along. All words are simple, repeated frequently, presented through speech bubbles, so young children will have an easy time following along. Although the story might feel unfinished or stir up a few questions- why do they simply give up while concerned their friend is missing, and why were they not aware of Goose’s planned vacation? – those not overly concerned with plot will enjoy the silly hijinks and the chant-like quality of the words.
Things I Should Have Known, written by Claire LaZebnik, reviewed by Bethany Bratney
Straight Talk for Librarians: The absolute strength of this book is its insightful, realistic depictions of family life and sibling relationships with a person on the autism spectrum. Ivy and Ethan’s characterization is perceptive and authentic, as are Chloe and David’s interactions with their siblings. This book is worthy of purchase for these depictions alone as they are the primary focus on the story. The romance between David and Chloe is satisfying in its slow burn, enemies-to-lovers storyline and in Chloe’s realization of the power of having deep, meaningful relationships based on shared experiences and mutual understanding and acceptance. That being said, many of Chloe’s other relationships are superficial and make the story lag a bit. Several of the adult characters are quite frustrating as well, but offer some context as to why the sibling relationships between Chloe and Ivy and David and Ethan are so special. Some teen sexual activity makes this a better bet for high school students. This book will appeal most to teens who have a close relationship with someone with special needs, or to those who are interested in gaining insight into the lives of those who do. A solid choice for adding much-needed neurodiversity representation to a collection.
The Grand Escape, written by Neal Bascomb, reviewed by Bethany Bratney
Monday, December 12, 2022
Ink in the Blood, written by Kim Smejkal, reviewed by Stephanie Wilson
Summary: Celia and Anya have been friends since their apprentice days. Each holds the mysterious power to transmit tattoos to other people via the ink that runs in their blood. Their “gift” is controlled by the orders of Divine. Celia and Anya long for a life beyond the temple walls. They plot their escape with the help of a fallen mistico (priestess) and join the Rabble Mob. The Rabble Mob is a traveling theater troupe that performs morality plays within the careful constraints of the Divine. Celia and Anya soon learn their past won’t be so easily escaped.
Straight Talk for Librarians: Ink in the Blood is a dark fantasy novel filled with characters whose gender is unknown or shifts. The lack of consistency leads to some confusion as to which character is speaking in parts of the novel. It is especially confusing when one character refers to another as "he" on one page and "she" on the following page. It was unclear whether this was intentional or due to spotty editing. Consistent use of the convention of they or we would have made more sense. The individual characters of the Rabble Mob are frequently more interesting than either Celia or Anya. Celia’s weakness, whining and moping is irritating. Act I of the book moves incredibly slow. The pace picks up in Act II and it's the best written section of the novel. The novel is clearly meant for high school level readers. There are multiple references to drinking absinthe with predictable consequences. Celia finds herself in several romantic entanglements that stop short of being sexual encounters. A character gouges her eyes out and multiple characters go mad.
It's clear the author completed tons of worldbuilding before the novel was written. Unfortunately, some of this previous work needed to be included in the novel for clarity's sake. The novel has good bones, but they never get fleshed out. I enjoyed parts of the novel but not the entire novel. The novel is book one of a planned series.
Wednesday, December 7, 2022
Honestly Ben, written by Bill Konigsberg, reviewed by Bethany Bratney
Straight Talk for Librarians: There were several concepts in this book that really worked for me. I loved how Ben’s character was pushing against traditional and sometimes toxic concepts of masculinity. He challenged teammates who made sexist or objectifying remarks and had in depth conversations with Hannah about aspects of the patriarchal society that bothered her. I also really appreciated how Konigsberg depicted the stress that Ben was under in a high-stakes education environment, in the running for a competitive scholarship and leading the baseball team as captain. It felt very realistic to me and I think students at my school will really relate to those dynamics. The big issue for conversation in this book is Ben’s attraction to his best friend, Rafe, his process of understanding those feelings and his need to combat some internalized homophobia in order to express them. Some aspects of this issue were handled really well, like the depiction of Ben’s thought process as he tried to make sense of having feelings for another male, which were entirely new to him. There were other aspects that I felt conflicted about, like Ben’s thoughts about bisexuality and his ultimate decision to identify as straight, but attracted to Rafe, often referred to as the “gay for you” trope. On one hand, I thought Ben really considered the many labels that he could apply to himself and consciously chose not to embrace the term bisexuality, which I see and validate as Ben's authentic feelings in that moment and he desire to not use a label that doesn't seem to fit him. On the other hand, I recognize that this trope can be problematic, especially in the bisexual community, and can be seen to reinforce some negative bi stereotypes which makes me hesitant to recommend it heavily. Ultimately, I intend to add this book to my collection, but I would recommend that other libraries add other titles to their LGBTQIA+ offerings first before considering the inclusion of this book. It seems that there are other titles that more successfully accomplish what this book attempts to do.
Graceling: the Graphic Novel, written by Kristin Cashore, adapted and illustrated by Gareth Hinds, reviewed by Bethany Bratney
Straight Talk for Librarians: This is a graphic adaptation of the 2008 bestselling fantasy novel and it is masterfully done. The story holds up well without aging itself as it takes place in a fictional land with little technology. Illustrator and adaptor Gareth Hinds artwork is incredible, capturing the essence of the original story and leaving little out. The fight scenes, which are plenty thanks to the specific Graces of Katsa and Po, are particularly impressive, as are the way in which Hinds handles Katsa’s internal thoughts. A specific feature of Gracelings is their two-colored eyes, which are striking in the graphic version. The inclusion of different skin tones and hair types amongst the characters from different lands is particularly welcome in this updated version. Many students will be drawn to this exciting fantasy graphic novel and it may even draw some readers to the original series as well. A highly recommended purchase for middle school and high school libraries.
Tuesday, December 6, 2022
I’m a Hare, So There, written by Julie Rowan-Zoch, reviewd by Terry Wahrman
Straight Talk for Librarians: The story explains the difference between a hare and a rabbit along with several other animals. The violence and characters are similar to the 1950-1980s TV cartoons. I ask myself does nostalgia make this book acceptable to so many on Amazon?
There are better ways to handle situations when someone calls you something you are not. Hare gets upset when called a rabbit. Hare goes on a rant to explain differences between himself and a rabbit as well as other animals like turtle vs tortoise. When caught by Coyote and called a rabbit, Hare punches Coyote in the nose and knocks him out, even though Coyote was chasing Hare. This book would promote a great discussion of what not to do and how to better handle situations.
100 Animals, written by Steve Jenkins, reviewed by Terry Wahrman
Friday, December 2, 2022
Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes (Hunger Games Prequel), written by Suzanne Collins, reviewed by Terry Wahrman
Thursday, December 1, 2022
How it Ends, written by Catherine Lo, reviewed by Stephanie Wilson
Straight Talk for Librarians: How it Ends deals with tough topics in an unflinching manner. The voices of both girls are distinctive, even without the chapter endings the delineation between characters is clear. Jessie’s anxiety is presented realistically. The way her mom and Annie try to “help” Jessie will feel familiar to any teen who struggles with anxiety and bullying. Annie’s relationship with her stepmom and stepsister is realistically portrayed. The novel contains mature content: references to mental illness, underage drinking, sex, pregnancy, and abortion. I highly recommend this novel for readers high school age or older. The mature content might make it a controversial addition to a middle school library.